Buy a pellet grill if you want to smoke for hours with a thermostat doing the babysitting. Buy a gas grill if most of your cooks are weeknight burgers, chicken, and vegetables that need a hot grate in 10 minutes. Both run only outdoors, and the real cost difference shows up in fuel per hour, not sticker price.

Side by Side

FactorPellet grillGas (propane) grill
FuelHardwood pellets, fed by an augerPropane cylinder or natural gas line
Fuel use per hourAbout 1 lb at low smoking temperatures, about 2 lb at high heat (Kingsford guidance, not a hard spec)Input in Btu/h divided by about 20,000 Btu per lb of propane
Needs electricityYes, for the auger, fan, and igniterUsually no, apart from battery igniters
Smoke flavorBuilt in from the fuelNeeds a smoke box or tube
Ready to cookPreheat for the controller to stabilizeShort preheat, then a hot grate
CleanupAsh in the fire pot, grease pathGrease tray and burners

The Fuel Math

DOE’s Alternative Fuels Data Center lists propane at about 84,250 Btu per gallon (lower heating value). At a common planning figure of 4.2 lb per gallon, that is about 20,060 Btu per pound. A grill rated at 30,000 Btu/h input, run flat out, burns 30,000 / 20,060 = about 1.5 lb per hour. At half input that drops to about 0.75 lb per hour. A 20 lb cylinder holds roughly 400,000 Btu (20 x 20,060), so at 30,000 Btu/h that is about 13 hours of full-burner grilling (403,200 / 30,000), and more at medium.

A pellet grill at 1 to 2 lb per hour is in the same range by weight. The difference is the price per pound. Use this formula with your own receipts: cost per hour = (price of the bag or cylinder / pounds in it) x pounds burned per hour. For a long brisket cook of 10 hours at 1.5 lb per hour, you burn 15 lb of pellets. The same 10 hours on a gas grill at half of that 30,000 Btu/h input would burn about 7 to 8 lb of propane (0.75 x 10).

Our guide to using a pellet grill in cold weather covers why winter cooks burn more.

Four Differences That Matter

Searing and speed

Gas puts heat on the grate almost at once and holds it at the high end, which suits steaks, chops, and quick vegetables. Pellet grills work through a controller that feeds fuel to hold a set temperature. Check each pellet model listed maximum temperature against what you want to sear at before you buy.

Smoke

Pellets are the fuel, so smoke comes with the cook. A gas grill can add smoke with a tube or box, but long low cooks eat more propane and need more attention.

Power dependence

A pellet grill stops if the power does. Our piece on running a pellet grill on a power station or generator has the wattage math. A gas grill keeps working in an outage, which is a real point for storm-prone homes.

Upkeep and safety

Pellet grills need ash and grease cleanup on a schedule; gas grills need burner and tray cleanup plus regular leak checks. Store cylinders outdoors and upright, as covered in how to store a propane tank safely.

Choose a Pellet Grill If

  • You smoke ribs, brisket, or pork shoulder most weekends.
  • You have an outdoor outlet within reach and want set-and-hold temperatures.

Choose a Gas Grill If

  • You cook short meals several nights a week.
  • You want grilling that works without electricity.
  • Searing is the priority and smoke is occasional.

Safety for Either Grill

Run both only outdoors, never in a garage, tent, or enclosed porch, because they produce carbon monoxide. Keep them well clear of the house, deck railings, and overhanging branches, and follow the clearances in your manual. NFPA advises keeping children and pets at least 3 feet from the grill and removing grease buildup from the grates and trays below. Check gas connections with soapy water; if you smell gas, shut off the cylinder valve, stay away from ignition sources, and call 911 or your gas supplier. Cook to USDA FSIS temperatures: 165°F for poultry, 160°F for ground meat, 145°F with a three-minute rest for whole cuts of beef, pork, and lamb.

FAQ

Is a pellet grill cheaper to run than gas?

It depends on local pellet and propane prices. Use the cost-per-hour formula above with your own receipts, since pellets run about 1 to 2 lb per hour and a 30,000 Btu/h gas grill up to about 1.5 lb per hour.

Can a pellet grill replace a gas grill?

For smoking and roasting, yes. If you rely on fast, very hot searing or cook during outages, a gas grill still fills a role.

Does a gas grill need a smoker accessory to smoke?

Yes. A smoke tube or box adds smoke, but it does not match a pellet grill for long unattended cooks.

For how we weigh specs and safety guidance, see how we choose.

Changelog: November 2026: first published.