Buy the Weber 22 inch kettle if you want 363 sq in of grate and easy moving; buy a kamado if you want ceramic, a 225 to 750°F stated range and the ability to smoke for hours, and you can live with a heavy body (Kamado Joe pages list about 188 lb and up). Of the kamados below, only Big Joe III (450 sq in) out-sizes the Weber kettle.
Weber® Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Weber® Jumbo Joe Premium Compact Charcoal Grill
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Specs Side by Side
| Model | Cooking area (sq in) | Weight (lb) | Stated range | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weber Original Kettle Premium 22 in | 363 | Not listed | None published | 10 years limited |
| Weber Jumbo Joe Premium 22 in (1321001) | 363 | Not listed | None published | 10 years limited |
| Kamado Joe Classic Joe | 250 | About 188 to 281, by model and page | 225 to 750°F | Limited lifetime badge |
| Big Green Egg Large | 262 | Not on the maker page | Not stated on page | Lifetime (terms not on page) |
| Kamado Joe Big Joe III | 450 | 406.3 | 225 to 750°F | Limited lifetime badge |
Sources are amer.weber.com, kamadojoe.com and biggreenegg.com. Kamado Joe pages disagree on weights between models and pages, so confirm your model before you plan a lift or a deck load. For a broader kamado-versus-kettle overview, read kamado vs kettle grill; this page narrows it to specific models.
What Separates Them
Grate area per footprint
Ratios against the 363 sq in Weber: Classic Joe is 250 / 363 = 0.69, Big Green Egg Large is 262 / 363 = 0.72, and Big Joe III is 450 / 363 = 1.24. Weber’s page says the kettle fits up to 13 burgers, so a Large Egg holds about 9 (0.72 times 13) and a Classic Joe about 9 (0.69 times 13) by the same density. Rough numbers, but it shows the gap for a family cook-out.
Weight and where it sits
Big Joe III is listed at 406.3 lb, and the Classic III at 280.6 lb. The Weber pages list no weight at all; the Jumbo Joe Premium has two wheels and an ash catcher, and stands 38.6 in high with the lid closed. Ceramic grills belong on a patio slab or a rated cart, not a light deck.
Low and slow versus quick and hot
Kamado Joe states 225 to 750°F for both its Classic III and Big Joe III. We found no temperature range on Weber’s pages for either kettle; you control heat with the vents and lid thermometer. Kamado Joe also tells you to burp the lid, cracking the dome 2 to 3 in for about 5 seconds before opening fully. A kettle gives you less to manage, but owners commonly add fuel more often on long cooks.
Premium versus Jumbo Joe Premium
Both Weber models list 363 sq in and a 10 year limited warranty. The Jumbo Joe Premium has two all-weather wheels and an ash catcher, and Weber says it has room for 6 to 8 people. Pick on how you move it, not on grate size. For more kettles see best kettle grills.
Choose a Weber Kettle If
- You grill burgers, chicken and steaks for a family or small group (Weber says the Jumbo Joe Premium has room for 6 to 8 people).
- You need a grill you can roll or lift.
- You would rather spend on fuel and tools than on a ceramic body.
- Look elsewhere if you want a stated 225°F low end for all-day smokes.
Choose a Kamado If
- You smoke pork shoulder or brisket and want a stated 225°F low end (Kamado Joe states one; Big Green Egg’s page does not).
- You have a permanent, load-rated spot for a heavy ceramic body (Kamado Joe pages list 188 lb and up).
- You want 450 sq in in one grill (Big Joe III). Compare brands in Kamado Joe vs Big Green Egg and best kamado grills.
Safety
CPSC says: never use a grill indoors or in a garage, breezeway, carport, porch or under a surface that will burn. Keep either grill away from the house, rails and eaves (NFPA). Let used coals cool fully and store them in a metal container with a lid.
FAQ
Is a Weber kettle a kamado?
No. A kettle is a thin porcelain-enameled steel bowl; a kamado is a thick ceramic cooker. See what is a kamado grill.
Can a kettle smoke as well as a kamado?
It can smoke with indirect coals and wood chunks, but owners commonly adjust vents and add fuel more often.
How do you score these?
We research specs and maker pages and do not use or review the products ourselves; see how we choose.
Changelog: November 2026: first published.