If the battery gets drained and recharged often, choose LiFePO4: Battle Born rates its 100 Ah LiFePO4 at 3,000 to 5,000 cycles, while Victron rates a 110 Ah AGM at 600 cycles to 50 percent depth of discharge. If the battery mostly floats on a charger, as in a sump pump backup, a sealed AGM can still be the better fit.

No Amazon listing in our product data is a LiFePO4 counterpart to an AGM battery, so this page has no product cards. Figures come from Battle Born and Victron material, plus the PumpSpy listing noted below.

LiFePO4 vs AGM Side by Side

LiFePO4 (lithium iron phosphate) is a lithium chemistry; AGM (absorbent glass mat) is a sealed lead-acid design. The LiFePO4 column is Battle Born’s 100 Ah, 12 V battery. The AGM column is Victron’s 12 V, 110 Ah deep cycle AGM, from Victron’s GEL and AGM battery datasheet.

SpecLiFePO4 (100 Ah, 12 V)AGM (110 Ah, 12 V)
Rated cycles3,000 to 5,000 (Battle Born)600 at 50% depth of discharge; 400 at 80% (Victron)
Recommended use of rated capacity80 to 100%, per Battle BornAbout 50%
Weight31 lb32 kg (about 70.5 lb)
Self-dischargeAbout 2 to 3% a month (Battle Born)Under 2% a month at 68°F (Victron); Battle Born’s page says 10 to 35% for AGM
Float design lifeNot a headline figure7 to 10 years at 68°F (Victron)
Charging in coldBattery management system (BMS) blocks charging near freezing; Battle Born’s manual says 32°F for standard modelsNo BMS cutoff
Maker warranty10 years (Battle Born)1 year on the PumpSpy sump AGM listing

The cycle ratings are vendor figures at different depths of discharge, so treat the gap as a direction, not a lab result. Battle Born’s own comparison page also states the lithium advantage as both “10x” and “5 to 10 times” in different places.

The Differences That Matter

Lifetime energy, not cycle count

Usable energy per cycle x rated cycles shows what each battery delivers over its life. LiFePO4: 12 V x 100 Ah = 1,200 Wh, times 100% use, times 3,000 cycles (the low end) = 3,600 kWh. AGM: 12 V x 110 Ah = 1,320 Wh, times 0.5 use, times 600 cycles = about 396 kWh. That is 3,600 / 396 = about 9 times the lifetime energy.

Cost per cycle follows from the same ratio, without quoting any price: the LiFePO4 battery pays for itself on throughput if it costs less than about 9 times the AGM of this size. Check current prices against that multiple.

How often you cycle sets the real life

Divide rated cycles by cycles per year. Cycling daily from solar: AGM 600 / 365 = about 1.6 years, LiFePO4 3,000 / 365 = about 8 years. Cycling once a week: AGM 600 / 52 = about 11 years, but Victron’s 7 to 10 year float life becomes the limit first. Rare use erases most of the cycle advantage.

Weight per usable amp-hour

A 110 Ah AGM used to 50% gives 55 Ah, and 70.5 lb / 55 Ah = about 1.3 lb per usable Ah. The 100 Ah LiFePO4 gives about 100 Ah, and 31 lb / 100 Ah = about 0.3 lb per Ah, roughly 4 times lighter. This matters for RV and portable builds, not for a battery bolted down in a basement.

Charging and cold

LiFePO4 needs a charger with the right profile; Battle Born lists 14.2 to 14.6 V for charging. A BMS also shuts off charging near freezing, which matters in an unheated garage or crawlspace. See what a battery management system does.

A Sump Pump Backup, Worked Through

Wayne’s WSB1275 is a 75 Ah AGM that the maker recommends for its WSS30VN backup sump system, and the PumpSpy PS1275 is a similar 75 Ah AGM. Take an assumed 12 V backup pump drawing 15 A (read your pump’s label for the real figure): 75 Ah x 0.5 usable / 15 A = 2.5 hours of continuous pumping. A 100 Ah LiFePO4 at full use would give 100 / 15 = about 6.7 hours.

That gap is real, but the battery sits idle most years, so cycle life barely counts. A sump backup system is built around a specific charger and battery type. Use the battery your pump maker’s manual names, and hire a licensed electrician for any wiring change. Our power stations for sump pumps guide covers the other route.

Choose LiFePO4 If

  • You cycle the battery weekly or daily, as with RV living or a solar bank.
  • Weight matters, or you need most of the rated amp-hours.
  • You want a long warranty and your charger supports lithium.
  • Skip it if your device’s manual names a lead-acid battery and charger, or the battery sits below freezing where it must charge.

Choose AGM If

  • The battery floats on a charger and rarely discharges, as in a UPS or sump backup.
  • The equipment was designed around lead-acid charging.
  • Skip it if you need more than 50% of the rated capacity every day.

Related reading: what LiFePO4 is, LiFePO4 vs NMC, and how long power stations last. We research and compare published specs; we do not run our own product trials. See how we choose.

FAQ

Can I swap a LiFePO4 battery into a sump pump backup?

Only if the pump maker says so. Backup systems are designed around a specific battery type and charger, so follow the manual and have a licensed electrician handle any change.

Is a 3,000-cycle LiFePO4 really 5 times better than a 600-cycle AGM?

Not exactly. The ratings use different depths of discharge, and both come from makers. The usable-energy math above gives a better comparison than cycles alone.

Does LiFePO4 need a battery management system?

Yes. The BMS protects the cells from over-charge, over-discharge, and out-of-range temperatures, and it is why charging can stop in the cold.

Changelog: November 2026: first published.