The Masterbuilt MPS 230S is the best starting point for most yards: a 30 inch vertical propane smoker with a 15,400 BTU burner, push-button ignition, and a 4.4 rating from 535 buyers. A 20 lb cylinder holds about 436,000 Btu of fuel, so the burner size sets how long a tank lasts. Pick the Dual Fuel model if you want to burn charcoal too.
Quick Comparison
| Smoker | Fuel | Cooking space | Listed weight | Rating (buyers) | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Masterbuilt MPS 230S | Propane, 15,400 BTU burner | 4 racks | 66.5 lb | 4.4 (535) | Most first-time gas smokers |
| Masterbuilt 30-Inch Dual Fuel | Propane and charcoal | 717 to 730 sq in (4 racks) | 59 lb | 4.4 (1,083) | Cooks who want both fuels |
| PIQUEBAR Propane Smoker with Cover | Propane | 3 racks | 55 lb | 4.6 (334) | Compact patios |
| Masterbuilt 40-inch ThermoTemp | Propane, dial to 375°F | 960 sq in (4 racks) | 92 lb | 4.0 (1,059) | Big batches, if you accept the lower rating |
How We Chose
We research and compare; we do not use or review the products ourselves. Our method uses listing data, maker information, and public buyer ratings. Every pick is a vertical smoker that burns propane (one also takes charcoal), judged from its listing. Three of the four score 4.4 or better; the 40-inch ThermoTemp is at 4.0, the lowest here, and we kept it only because it is the sole large-capacity option. The PIQUEBAR listing is thin on specs (no BTU rating, no cooking area), so confirm details with the seller.
Our Picks
Masterbuilt MPS 230S
- Masterbuilt MPS 230S lists four chrome-coated racks, a built-in temperature gauge, and a porcelain-coated flame disk bowl that shields the burner from grease.
- The listing gives a 15,400 BTU stainless-steel burner. Reading that as Btu per hour at full burn, a 20 lb cylinder lasts about 436,000 / 15,400 = 28 hours; real cooks run below full, so that is a ceiling.
- Listed weight is 66.5 lb at 20.5 x 20.9 x 43.5 inches.
Best for: a first propane smoker for a family of four. Avoid if: you want a rack count above four or a dial-set temperature.
Masterbuilt 30-Inch Dual Fuel
- Masterbuilt 30-Inch Dual Fuel runs on propane and charcoal, with push-button ignition, a type 1 regulator and hose, and a locking door with a temperature gauge.
- The listing shows 730 sq in in the title and 717 sq in in a bullet, so plan around the lower 717 sq in.
- It has more buyer ratings than the MPS 230S: 1,083 at 4.4.
- Charcoal adds ash handling to the propane chores, and like propane it makes carbon monoxide, so run it outdoors only.
Best for: cooks who want gas for easy runs and charcoal for flavor. Avoid if: you do not want to manage ash and two fuels.
Propane Smoker with Cover (DJ55130W)
- This vertical propane smoker lists three removable racks, accessible water and wood chip trays, a door that seals, and a cover in the package, at 4.6 from 334 buyers.
- Listed weight is 55 lb at 19.7 x 16.5 x 40.9 inches, the smallest footprint here.
- The listing gives no BTU rating and no cooking area, so it cannot be compared on fuel use. The listing warns never to run it with the chip tray or water pan removed and to keep its sides away from grass, leaves, and branches.
Best for: small decks and buyers who like a bundled cover. Avoid if: you need a maker-published BTU figure or warranty detail before you buy.
Masterbuilt 40-Inch ThermoTemp (optional)
- Masterbuilt 40-Inch ThermoTemp has 960 sq in, four racks, and a dial for temperatures up to 375°F. The listing says it holds up to 8 pork butts or 8 racks of ribs.
- The rating is the weak point: 4.0 across 1,059 buyers, below the others here. Warranty per the listing: 1 year limited.
- Listed weight is 92 lb at 53 inches tall; it needs a clear spot and a stable base.
Best for: holiday batches and small gatherings. Avoid if: you cook for two to four, or the 4.0 rating is a deal-breaker.
What to Look For
- Burner rating: a burner that holds 225°F matters more than a high BTU number.
- Ignition: push-button ignition saves matches near a gas valve.
- Door and trays: a tight door and a water pan and chip tray you can reach without opening it.
- Regulator and hose: the maker’s own parts only. Do not swap or alter them.
Sample fuel math
EIA lists propane at 91,452 Btu per gallon, and about 4.2 lb per gallon is a common planning figure, so 1 lb is roughly 21,800 Btu. A 20 lb cylinder holds about 20 lb of propane, giving 20 x 21,800 = 436,000 Btu. If a smoker averages 10,000 Btu per hour (an assumed example, not a rating), a cylinder lasts about 44 hours (436,000 / 10,000 = 43.6). Check the maker’s own consumption figure.
Propane vs Electric Smoker
An electric smoker is simpler: one listing for a 30-inch unit shows 800 W, so an 8 hour cook is 0.8 kW x 8 h = 6.4 kWh at your local rate. It needs a dry outlet and cord. Propane skips the outlet but adds cylinder swaps and a leak check. If you are new to smoking, best smokers for beginners starts with electric; the full trade-off is in gas smoker vs electric smoker. For gas basics see best gas grills.
Propane Safety
- CPSC says: “Never use a grill indoors or in a garage, breezeway, carport, porch or under a surface that will burn.” That applies to a propane smoker. Burning gas or charcoal makes carbon monoxide, so use it outdoors only.
- Check for leaks with soapy water: brush it on the hose and connections with the valve open and the burners off. Bubbles mean a leak. Walk through how to check a propane grill for leaks.
- If you smell gas, shut off the cylinder valve, keep flames and sparks away, and call your gas supplier or 911.
- Keep cylinders upright and outside; see how to store a propane tank.
- Do not repair a valve or regulator yourself, and do not convert fuels. Use the maker’s kit or a technician.
- Keep the smoker away from the house, railings, eaves, and branches per NFPA and the manual. Keep children and pets back.
For food safety, use a thermometer: USDA FSIS says 165°F for poultry, 160°F for ground meat, and 145°F with a 3 minute rest for whole cuts of beef, pork, and lamb.
Cost of Ownership
Budget for cylinder refills, wood chips (gas gives no smoke by itself), a cover, and a probe thermometer.
FAQ
Is a propane smoker better than electric?
It is better where there is no outlet; electric is simpler where there is one.
How often should I check for leaks?
Each time you connect a new cylinder, and after the smoker has been stored or moved.
Can I run it on a covered porch?
No. CPSC lists porches and surfaces that can burn as places never to use a grill. Browse the Outdoor Cooking guide for placement basics.
Changelog: November 2026: first published.