A kettle is the better first charcoal grill for direct grilling and burgers on a budget; a kamado earns its extra cost and bulk if you want long, low smoking sessions and wide temperature control. On the maker’s numbers a 22-inch Weber kettle gives you 363 sq in of grate, while an 18-inch Kamado Joe Classic Joe II gives 250 sq in and a 225 to 750°F range.

Side by Side

FactorWeber 22-inch Original KettleKamado Joe Classic Joe II (18-inch)
BodyPorcelain-enameled steel bowl and lidCeramic
Cooking area363 sq in (Weber)250 sq in; 407 with grill expander (Kamado Joe)
Stated heat rangeNone published; lid thermometer and dampers225 to 750°F (Kamado Joe)
WeightNot listed on the Weber page; three aluminum legs and two wheelsAbout 215 to 228 lb on the cart, depending on the Kamado Joe page
Ash handlingOne-Touch ash catcherSee the manual for your model
Warranty10 years limited (Weber)Check the current Kamado Joe terms

Kamado Joe’s own pages disagree on the standalone weight, from 188 to 214.5 lb, so confirm before you plan a lift or a deck load. Weber’s page lists 363 sq in in the spec table; a caption elsewhere on the page cites a different figure, so we use the table.

Differences That Matter

Grate space

The kettle has 363 / 250 = about 1.45 times the grate of the 18-inch kamado. Kamado Joe’s expander and extra grates raise its total to 407 to 660 sq in, but those are add-ons. For a family of four doing burgers, the plain kettle already has more room.

Fuel and long cooks

Kingsford suggests about 2 to 3 lb of briquets for medium heat and about 4 lb for high heat on a 22-inch grill, which suits a kettle for an evening cook. For an all-day smoke, the kamado’s stated range starts at 225°F, and its ceramic body is built to hold heat. A thin steel kettle has no stated low end, so expect to manage vents and add fuel more often. If long smokes are your goal, also read best charcoal smokers.

Searing and heat range

Kamado Joe lists up to 750°F, well above the 450 to 550°F Kingsford describes as high heat for a single zone. Weber publishes no rated range for the kettle; it gives you dampers and a lid thermometer. The kettle’s high-heat zone fits that 450 to 550°F band; only the kamado states a higher ceiling.

Weight and placement

A ceramic grill listed at roughly 190 to 230 lb is a permanent fixture; it will not move easily on stairs or a small deck. Check the deck or patio rating before buying. The kettle is a two-wheel, three-leg grill you can reposition.

Choose a Kettle If

  • You grill burgers, chicken and steaks and want to spend less.
  • You want more grate area from a lighter grill.
  • You have limited space or a deck with weight limits.

Choose a Kamado If

  • You smoke pork shoulder, brisket or ribs for hours and want steady low heat.
  • You cook year round; see how to smoke meat in cold weather.
  • You can place a heavy grill permanently on a solid surface.
  • Look elsewhere if you want a quick weeknight grill; gas vs charcoal covers that choice.

Safety

Use either grill outdoors only. CPSC says: never use a grill indoors or in a garage, breezeway, carport, porch or under a surface that will burn. Keep both away from the house, deck railings and eaves (NFPA). Let used coals cool fully and keep them in a metal container with a lid. USDA FSIS targets apply to both: 165°F for poultry, 160°F for ground meat, 145°F with a 3 minute rest for whole beef, pork and lamb cuts.

FAQ

Can a kettle smoke meat?

Yes, with indirect coals and wood chunks, though you tend the fire more than on a kamado.

Is a kamado worth it for casual grilling?

Usually not. Its strengths show on long cooks; for quick direct grilling a kettle does the same job with more grate.

Where do I compare kamado models?

See best kamado grills and best charcoal grills. We research specs and do not use or review the products ourselves; see how we choose.

Changelog: November 2026: first published.