For most backyards, start with a 22-inch Weber kettle: 363 sq in of grate holds about a dozen burgers, and the vents are simple enough to learn in one weekend. Go smaller for a patio or campsite. Go barrel-style if you want a big grate for the money.
Quick Comparison
| Grill | Style | Main grate | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weber Original Kettle 22-inch | Kettle | 363 sq in | First charcoal grill |
| Weber Original Kettle Premium 22-inch | Kettle | 363 sq in | Frequent cooks who hate ash cleanup |
| Weber Jumbo Joe 18-inch | Tabletop kettle | 240 sq in | Small patio, two to four people |
| Oklahoma Joe’s Rambler | Tabletop, cast iron grate | 218 sq in | Searing at a campsite or tailgate |
| Royal Gourmet CC1830 | Barrel with cart | 434 sq in plus warming rack | Crowds on a tight budget |
| Royal Gourmet CC1830S | Barrel with offset smoker box | 434 sq in plus smoker box | Trying low and slow smoking |
How We Chose
We research and compare from published specs, manuals, and buyer feedback; we do not use or review the products ourselves. The inputs are spec sheets, manufacturer documents, the listing details for each grill, and ratings from verified buyers, which feed the Yard & Grid Score explained on How We Choose. Grate area, vent and damper design, ash handling, build material, and warranty carried the most weight. Where a listing disagrees with itself, we say so rather than pick a number.
Our Picks
Weber Original Kettle 22-inch
- Weber’s count is 13 burgers on 363 sq in with a burger press, about 28 sq in each.
- Porcelain-enameled lid and bowl, aluminum damper, and a One-Touch ash catcher that sweeps ash from the bowl.
- The listing shows 4.8 stars from 10,229 reviews and a 10 year limited warranty; read Weber’s terms for what it covers.
Best for: a first charcoal grill and anyone who wants the most owner feedback behind a purchase. Avoid if: you want a built-in lid thermometer, which the listing mentions only for the Premium version.
Weber Original Kettle Premium 22-inch
- Same 22-inch bowl as the Original; the listing adds a lid thermometer, a hinged cooking grate, and a removable high-capacity ash catcher.
- The hinged grate lets you add coals mid-cook without lifting the whole grate.
Best for: weekly grillers who add fuel during long cooks. Avoid if: the extras are not worth the step up from the Original, since the cooking area does not change.
Weber Jumbo Joe 18-inch
- Weber lists 240 sq in on an 18.5-inch grate; one spec field on the Amazon listing says 100.48 sq in, which does not match Weber’s page.
- Porcelain-enameled bowl and lid, aluminum dampers, and a listed weight of 18 lb.
Best for: a balcony-sized yard where rules allow charcoal, or a second grill for the trunk. Avoid if: you cook for more than four people at once.
Oklahoma Joe’s Rambler
- 218 sq in with thick cast iron grates; the listing says six steaks or burgers fit.
- A height-adjustable charcoal tray lets you move the fire closer for searing or farther for gentler heat.
- The listing shows a 2 year warranty on all parts and a listed weight of 48.5 lb.
Best for: searing steaks for two to four. Avoid if: you want to carry it far, since 48.5 lb is heavy for a tabletop grill.
Royal Gourmet CC1830 barrel
- 585 sq in listed: 434 sq in of cooking grate plus a 151 sq in warming rack. At the Weber ratio of 28 sq in per burger, the main grate holds about 15.
- Two-level charcoal pan, side shelf, lid thermometer, and two wheels.
Best for: cookouts with a crowd and a small budget. Avoid if: you want a heavy porcelain-enameled body; the listing describes powder-coated alloy steel, and only the grates are porcelain-enameled.
Royal Gourmet CC1830S barrel with offset smoker
- 783 sq in listed in total: 434.3 sq in main grate, 151.0 sq in warming rack, and a 197.4 sq in smoker box.
- The offset box attaches to the side, so smoke flows from a separate fire into the cook chamber.
Best for: someone curious about smoking who has the time to manage two fires. Avoid if: you want set-and-hold temperatures; a pellet or gas grill is easier on that front.
Cost of Ownership
Fuel is the running cost. Kingsford suggests about 2 to 3 lb of briquets for medium heat and about 4 lb for high heat on a 22-inch grill, so three high-heat cooks a weekend is about 12 lb. Add a chimney starter, a grill cover, and a metal bucket with a tight lid for ashes. Check the warranty terms before you buy, since coverage differs by brand and the listings summarize it loosely. For a fuel comparison with gas, see gas grill vs charcoal grill.
Set It Up Safely
Burn charcoal outdoors only. The CPSC lists garages among the enclosed spaces where charcoal must never be used, because it gives off carbon monoxide; the basics are on why you cannot grill indoors. NFPA advises placing the grill away from the house, deck railings, eaves, and overhanging branches, and keeping children and pets at least 3 ft away. Browse the rest of the silo in the Outdoor Cooking guide. Let ashes cool completely and store them in a metal container with a tight lid, never straight into a trash can. Cook to USDA FSIS temperatures: 165°F for poultry, 160°F for ground meat, and 145°F with a 3 minute rest for whole cuts of beef, pork, and lamb.
How to Pick
- How many do you feed? Divide the grate area by 28 sq in per burger. A 363 sq in kettle is about 13; a 218 sq in tabletop is about 8 by the same ratio, though its listing says six.
- Where will it sit? Check lease, HOA, and fire rules before buying a charcoal grill for a balcony.
- Do you want to smoke? A kettle with a two-zone fire handles ribs and chicken; the offset box adds a second fire to manage.
- How much cleanup do you accept? Larger ash catchers mean fewer emptying trips.
FAQ
What is the best charcoal grill for beginners?
The 22-inch Weber Original Kettle: one bowl, two vents, and a wide base of owner feedback. Learn to bank coals to one side before you add accessories.
Is a bigger grate always better?
No. A larger grate needs more fuel to hold the same heat and takes more room. Size to your usual guest count.
Can I use a charcoal grill under a covered patio?
Keep it well clear of any roof, eave, or wall and in open air. Follow the grill’s manual and local fire rules, and do not use it in a garage or enclosed porch.
Changelog: November 2026: first published.