For most buyers the two ceramic cookers are close enough that price, dealer support and accessories decide it; Big Green Egg lists slightly more grate in the 18-inch class (262 sq in for the Large EGG against 250 sq in on the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III), while Kamado Joe lists a stated 225 to 750°F range.
Specs Side by Side
| Spec | Kamado Joe Classic Joe III | Big Green Egg Large |
|---|---|---|
| Grate diameter | 18 in (Kamado Joe) | 18.25 in (retailer listings) |
| Cooking area | 250 sq in | 262 sq in |
| Weight | 280.6 lb (Kamado Joe page) | About 162 lb for the EGG alone (retailer listings) |
| Stated temperature range | 225 to 750°F | Check Big Green Egg’s current page |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime (Kamado Joe page) | Lifetime warranty (terms on Big Green Egg’s warranty page) |
Weights are not like for like: Kamado Joe’s figure likely includes the cart, while the Big Green Egg figure is the ceramic EGG alone; a nest package listing shows 182 lb. Kamado Joe’s own pages have also shown different weights for the earlier Classic Joe II, so confirm the figure for your exact model. Big Green Egg has no ASIN in our product pool, so the comparison follows the makers’ pages and retailer listings, and only the Kamado Joe side links to a product listing. Big Green Egg’s own Large EGG page shows 262 sq in and a lifetime warranty but not the grid diameter or weight, so those two come from retailers.
Differences That Matter
Grate area by size
Area is pi times radius squared. A 24-inch grate is 3.14 x 12 x 12 = about 452 sq in, close to the 450 sq in Kamado Joe lists for the Big Joe III. A Big Green Egg XL with a 24-inch grid would give the same circle, but that is our geometric estimate, not a Big Green Egg figure. At 18 inches the math gives 3.14 x 9 x 9 = about 254 sq in, and at 18.25 inches about 262 sq in. The practical gap between the two brands at the same nominal size is small. Kamado Joe also sells add-on grates and expanders to stack levels, which raise usable area but cost extra.
Weight and placement
Kamado Joe lists the Big Joe III at 406.3 lb. A ceramic cooker this heavy needs a solid, level surface, and a wooden deck needs a load check first. Ask the maker for the supported weight of any stand or table you plan to use.
Accessories carry across
Some third-party gear fits both: the listing for this Kamado Joe Big Joe grill cover says it also fits the XL Big Green Egg and other round 24-inch grills. That is a listing claim, so compare the cover dimensions with your own grill before ordering.
Temperature habits
Both brands advise opening the dome slowly at high heat. Kamado Joe says to burp the lid each time, cracking the dome 2 to 3 inches for about five seconds before opening fully; check Big Green Egg’s manual for its own burping guidance. Neither is a quick-start gas grill, so allow time for the ceramic to heat. For the wider kamado picture, see best kamado grills and kamado vs kettle grill.
Choose Kamado Joe If
- You like built-in features such as Divide and Conquer cooking levels and the SloRoller smoke insert.
- You want a stated range of 225 to 750°F from the maker.
- You are comfortable with the weight shown above.
Choose Big Green Egg If
- You want the EGG alone at about 162 lb (retailer listings) and a wide choice of sizes.
- You are happy to buy through a dealer; read Big Green Egg’s warranty terms for any dealer requirement.
- Look elsewhere if you want a lighter, cheaper charcoal cooker; best charcoal grills covers other options.
Safety
Use either cooker outdoors only. CPSC says never use a grill indoors or in a garage, breezeway, carport, porch or under a surface that will burn. Keep it away from the house, railings and eaves (NFPA), and keep children and pets back from the hot ceramic. Let used coals cool fully and keep them in a metal container with a lid. USDA FSIS targets: 165°F for poultry, 160°F for ground meat, 145°F with a 3 minute rest for whole beef, pork and lamb.
FAQ
Are the two brands the same design?
Both are ceramic, egg-shaped charcoal cookers, but features, accessories and parts differ by brand.
Can I smoke on either?
Yes, kamados hold low heat for long cooks; see hot smoking vs cold smoking for the food safety side.
How do we pick between models?
We research specs and public ratings and do not use or review the products ourselves. Our method is in how we choose.
Changelog: November 2026: first published.