For most backyard kettles, 16 lb of Kingsford Original briquettes is the default: the listing says coals are ready in about 15 minutes, and buyers rate it 4.8 from 4,471 reviews. Pick hardwood lump such as FOGO or Jealous Devil when you want more sear heat or longer smokes in a kamado.
Quick Comparison
| Charcoal | Form | Bag size | Listing says | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kingsford Original | Briquettes | 16 lb | Ready in about 15 minutes | Everyday kettle cooks |
| FOGO Super Premium | Lump | 35 lb | Ready in about 15 minutes, about 80% pieces 4 in or longer | Searing and long smokes |
| Jealous Devil Chunx XL | Large lump | 35 lb | Over 1,100°F, low ash | Kamado and smoker fans |
| Masterbuilt Premium Hardwood | Lump | 16 lb | Made for Gravity Series, fits other grills | Masterbuilt owners |
| Kingsford Easy Light | Briquettes in a light-the-bag pack | 4 lb | Lights with a match, about 10 minutes | Camping and short cooks |
How We Chose
We research and compare; we do not use or review the products ourselves. Inputs are the Amazon listings and verified buyer ratings that feed the Yard & Grid Score on how we choose. Burn claims here come from the sellers, not from independent measurement, so treat them as the seller’s word. Only products with a clear fuel category and a usable spec sheet made the list. Ratings appear only where the listing shows a review count.
Our Picks
Kingsford Original Charcoal Briquettes, 16 lb
- The listing calls these briquettes made in the USA from real American wood, with grooves meant to speed ignition.
- It shows 4.8 stars from 4,471 reviews, the strongest buyer base in this pool.
- Kingsford’s own guide suggests about 2 to 3 lb for medium heat and about 4 lb for high heat on a 22-inch grill.
Best for: weekly kettle cooks. Avoid if: you want the lump look and fast response of pure hardwood.
FOGO Super Premium Hardwood Lump, 35 lb
- The listing says dense Central American hardwoods with no added ingredients, and about 80% of the bag in pieces 4 in or longer.
- Large pieces leave air gaps, which suits hot sears and long smokes in a kamado.
- The listing’s brand field reads GWSTORE and its manufacturer field Kebroak, so check what you receive before assuming a bag matches the FOGO site.
Best for: kamado and big kettle cooks. Avoid if: you need uniform pieces for a small tabletop grill.
Jealous Devil Chunx XL Lump, 35 lb
- The listing says dense South American quebracho blanco, over 1,100°F for searing, and a 20+ hour low-oxygen burn.
- It also claims low ash and 25% to 40% less charcoal for low smoking. Those are seller claims with no outside measurement.
- Big chunks need a big firebox, so check fit in a small kettle.
Best for: long overnight smokes. Avoid if: your grill holds only a few pounds of fuel.
Masterbuilt Premium Hardwood Lump, 16 lb
- The title says it is made for Gravity Series grills and fits barrel, kamado, and kettle grills too.
- The listing shows 4.4 stars from 2,691 reviews, the lowest rating here but still a large sample.
- The description is short, with no burn-time figures.
Best for: Gravity Series owners. Avoid if: you want published burn numbers before you buy.
Kingsford Easy Light Briquettes, 4 lb
- The pack lights with a match and no lighter fluid; the listing says ready in about 10 minutes.
- At 4 lb it covers one high-heat cook on a 22-inch grill by Kingsford’s guide.
- Follow the bag’s instructions exactly, and do not add lighter fluid to it.
Best for: camping and one-off cooks. Avoid if: you grill weekly; 4 lb is only one high-heat cook on a 22-inch grill.
Best Charcoal for Smoking
Charcoal sets the heat; the smoke flavor mostly comes from wood chunks you add. For a steady 225°F cook, choose a fuel you can hold in a bank and that leaves little ash to choke airflow. Pair either type with the wood in what wood to use for smoking meat, and see best charcoal smokers for grills built for it.
Cost of Ownership
Count fuel by cooks, not by bag. At about 4 lb per high-heat cook, a 16 lb bag gives 16 / 4 = 4 cooks and a 35 lb bag gives 35 / 4 = 8.75, so 8 full cooks, if lump burns at a similar weight. If the Jealous Devil claim of 25% to 40% less fuel held for a smoke that takes 10 lb of briquettes, you would load 6 to 7.5 lb. Add a metal bucket with a lid for spent coals and a chimney from best charcoal chimney starters.
Set It Up Safely
CPSC says: never use a grill indoors or in a garage, breezeway, carport, porch or under a surface that will burn. CPSC also says never to burn charcoal in tents, campers, vans, cars, trucks, homes, garages, or mobile homes, because carbon monoxide can kill. NFPA says that if you use starter fluid, use only charcoal starter fluid and never add it to coals that are already lit. It also advises keeping children and pets at least 3 ft away, and letting coals cool completely before moving them to a metal container with a tight lid, never straight into the trash. Cook to USDA FSIS temperatures: 165°F for poultry, 160°F for ground meat, and 145°F with a 3 minute rest for whole cuts.
How to Pick
- What grill do you own? Kettles handle either; kamados and Gravity Series grills favor lump.
- How often do you cook? Weekly means a 16 lb or 35 lb bag; occasional means the 4 lb pack.
- How long are your cooks? Divide cook hours by the burn time you expect from a full load, then keep one spare bag.
Grill choice drives this more than brand; compare in best charcoal grills and best kettle grills.
FAQ
Is lump or briquette charcoal better?
Neither wins everywhere. Briquettes are uniform and easy to dose; lump lights fast and burns hot but varies by bag.
How should I store charcoal?
Keep it dry. The Jealous Devil listing describes a resealable waterproof bag; for others, use a sealed bin away from damp floors.
Can I add lighter fluid to burning coals?
No. NFPA says never to add charcoal starter fluid to coals that are already lit, and a chimney starter avoids fluid entirely.
Changelog: November 2026: first published.