Smoke a pork shoulder at 225 to 250°F and plan on roughly 1.5 to 2 hours per pound, a common cook’s rule of thumb, not a guarantee. An 8 lb shoulder is 12 to 16 hours. Pork is safe at 145°F; you cook to about 195 to 205°F only because that is where pulled pork gets tender.

Safe Is Not the Same as Tender

USDA FSIS lists whole cuts of pork at 145°F with a 3 minute rest. A shoulder passes that early. It is still tough there, because the collagen has not broken down. The 195 to 205°F range cooks commonly quote for pulling is about texture, not food safety. Treat it as a target, and probe in several spots until the thermometer slides in with little resistance.

GoalInternal tempWhy
Safe to eat (USDA FSIS)145°F + 3 minute restFood safety minimum for whole pork
SliceableAround 180 to 190°FCook preference; still firm
PulledAround 195 to 205°FCook preference; collagen softens

Time Math

Weight x hours per pound = cook time. For an 8 lb bone-in shoulder: 8 x 1.5 = 12 hours, and 8 x 2 = 16 hours. Add a 1 to 2 hour rest, so a 6 p.m. dinner can mean lighting the smoker the night before. Start early; a shoulder held in a closed cooler wrapped in towels is a standard way to absorb a finish that came too soon.

Step by Step

  1. Thaw fully. FSIS says to thaw before smoking. An 8 lb shoulder needs days in the refrigerator, not hours.
  2. Trim and rub. Leave a thin fat cap. Wash hands and surfaces after handling raw pork.
  3. Hold 225 to 300°F. FSIS recommends that smoker air range. Most cooks sit at the low end, so 225 to 250°F.
  4. Probe two ways. One thermometer in the thickest part, away from bone, and one for smoker air. See best meat thermometers for smoking.
  5. Expect a stall. Cooks commonly report the internal temperature stalling for hours somewhere in the middle of the cook as moisture evaporates off the surface. Waiting it out is fine. Wrapping in foil or butcher paper is the usual shortcut, and it softens the bark.
  6. Pull at the target, rest 1 to 2 hours, then shred.
  7. Chill leftovers within 2 hours of cooking.

Pick a Smoker That Can Hold the Hours

A 12 to 16 hour cook is a fuel and attention problem. Pellet and electric units hold temperature unattended better than charcoal. Check hopper or tank capacity first; how many pellets a pellet grill uses gives a worked example. The trade-offs between styles are in electric vs pellet vs propane smokers, and an overnight cook is easier to plan with a reliable beginner smoker.

Safety and Mistakes

  • Cook outdoors only. Never use a grill indoors or in a garage, breezeway, carport, porch or under a surface that will burn (CPSC). More in why you can’t grill indoors.
  • Keep the cooker well away from the house, deck rail, and branches, and keep kids and pets back.
  • Never leave a hot cooker unattended. On an overnight cook, check fuel and temperature on a schedule.
  • Do not stop a cook partway and resume later.
  • Opening the lid constantly. It lengthens the cook.
  • Pulling by clock alone. The probe decides.

New to the cooker itself? Start with how to use a smoker for the first time. For how we weigh sources, see how we choose. We research and compare; we do not use or review the products ourselves.

Changelog: November 2026: first published.