Choose the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy for one room up to about 225 sq ft, such as a bedroom-sized space or a small cabin, and choose the Big Buddy for spaces up to about 450 sq ft, such as a two-car garage or an ice shanty, because the Big Buddy doubles the top output to 18,000 BTU and runs on two 1 lb cylinders instead of one.

Both are unvented propane heaters. They burn inside the room and release their exhaust there, so the ventilation rules and a working carbon monoxide (CO) alarm come before any comparison of features. Read the safety section below before you choose either one.

Mr. Heater 9,000 BTU Portable Buddy Radiant Propane Heater

Mr. Heater 9,000 BTU Portable Buddy Radiant

Propane Space Heaters
MrHeater
amazon.com
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
4.7 (29.3K reviews)
In Stock
$89.97
Updated: October 26, 2026
Price as of Oct 26, 2026. We earn from qualifying purchases.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.

Mr. Heater 18,000 BTU Big Buddy Heater NF

Mr. Heater 18,000 BTU Big Buddy Heater NF

Patio Heaters
MrHeater
amazon.com
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
4.6 (5.7K reviews)
In Stock
$144.99
Updated: October 26, 2026
Price as of Oct 26, 2026. We earn from qualifying purchases.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.

Buddy vs Big Buddy: Specs Side by Side

The figures below come from Mr. Heater’s product pages for the Portable Buddy (model MH9BX) and the Big Buddy (model MH18B). BTU here means British thermal units per hour of heat output.

SpecPortable Buddy (MH9BX)Big Buddy (MH18B)
Heat settings4,000 / 9,000 BTU4,000 / 9,000 / 18,000 BTU
Rated heating areaUp to 225 sq ftUp to 450 sq ft
BTU per sq ft at top setting9,000 / 225 = 4018,000 / 450 = 40
Cylinders on boardOne 1 lb cylinderTwo 1 lb cylinders
Rated run time on boardAbout 3 h high, 6 h low (one 1 lb)Up to 11 h (two 1 lb)
20 lb tankWith optional hose (most hoses also need a fuel filter)With optional hose (most hoses also need a fuel filter)
Low-oxygen shutoff (ODS)YesYes
Tip-over shutoffYesYes
Maximum altitude7,000 ft7,000 ft
FanNoneRemoved on some current models (the “NF” version)
Warranty3 year limited3 year limited

The BTU-per-square-foot row shows that Mr. Heater rates both heaters on the same 40 BTU per sq ft basis. The Big Buddy is the same heat recipe at twice the size, with a third setting in the middle.

The Four Differences That Matter

1. Heating area

Measure the room first. Room area = length x width. A 12 ft x 15 ft bedroom is 12 x 15 = 180 sq ft, inside the Buddy’s 225 sq ft rating. A 20 ft x 22 ft two-car garage is 20 x 22 = 440 sq ft, which only the Big Buddy’s 450 sq ft rating covers. Ratings assume a reasonably closed space; drafty garages, high ceilings, and very cold days all push the real need upward.

2. Run time and fuel

Run time follows from the heat stored in the propane. Using EIA’s figure of 91,452 BTU per gallon and a common planning figure of 4.2 lb per gallon of propane, one 1 lb cylinder holds about 91,452 / 4.2 = 21,800 BTU.

SetupSettingFormulaPlanning run time
Buddy, one 1 lb9,000 BTU21,800 / 9,000About 2.4 h
Buddy, one 1 lb4,000 BTU21,800 / 4,000About 5.4 h
Big Buddy, two 1 lb18,000 BTU43,600 / 18,000About 2.4 h
Big Buddy, two 1 lb4,000 BTU43,600 / 4,000About 10.9 h
Either, 20 lb tank9,000 BTU20 x 21,800 / 9,000About 48 h
Big Buddy, 20 lb tank18,000 BTU20 x 21,800 / 18,000About 24 h

Mr. Heater rates the Buddy at about 3 hours on high and 6 on low per cylinder, a little above the math (its product copy elsewhere says up to 5.4 hours, which matches the low-setting math), and the Big Buddy at up to 11 hours with both cylinders, which lines up with the low-setting math. Plan on the lower number, and less in deep cold: the manual notes reduced run time below 20°F. Mr. Heater also notes that a single 1 lb cylinder can run the Big Buddy only on low and medium, and that an undersized cylinder may frost over, which is why it takes two.

The 20 lb rows apply only to outdoor setups. The Buddy manual says never to bring a refillable cylinder indoors, and it says cylinders are not stored in a building, garage, or other enclosed area; indoor emergency use is with 1 lb cylinders. A 20 lb tank on the optional hose, with a fuel filter where the hose calls for one, suits an open-air job site or patio.

3. Settings and control

The Big Buddy’s middle 9,000 BTU setting is the practical difference in a smaller room. It can run at Buddy-level heat on two cylinders, which roughly doubles the time between cylinder swaps at that setting: 43,600 / 9,000 = about 4.8 hours versus about 2.4 hours for the Buddy. The Buddy has only two settings, so in a room near its limit it spends most of its time on high.

4. The fan question

Older Big Buddy units had a battery-powered blower fan. Mr. Heater says it has removed the fan on some models, citing import tariff changes, and the version in our card is listed as “NF,” meaning no fan. Older guides that mention the fan describe a different unit. Without it, both heaters are pure radiant heaters: they warm people and objects in front of them faster than they warm the air in the far corners.

Carbon Monoxide, Ventilation, and State Rules

Follow these steps in this order every time either heater runs indoors. Each one comes from the Mr. Heater manual or a public agency.

  1. Install CO alarms first. The CPSC advises CO alarms on every level of the home and outside sleeping areas. The heater’s low-oxygen sensor (ODS) shuts it off when oxygen drops; it does not measure carbon monoxide and does not replace an alarm.
  2. Open the fresh-air openings the manual specifies. The Portable Buddy manual calls for at least 9 sq in of opening near the ceiling and near the floor. The Big Buddy manual sets its own figure; use the number in your manual.
  3. Never run it while sleeping or unattended, as the manual states.
  4. Keep the clearances to walls, ceilings, and anything that can burn that the manual lists, and keep children and pets back from the grill.
  5. Stay below 7,000 ft. Mr. Heater lists 7,000 ft as the maximum altitude for both models; above that, the manual warns the heater may shut off.
  6. Know the symptoms. Headache, dizziness, and nausea can signal CO exposure. Turn the heater off, get to fresh air, and call 911 if anyone feels ill.

Some places restrict unvented heaters in homes. Mr. Heater states that Buddy heaters are restricted from all indoor use in Massachusetts and Canada and from use in dwellings in California, and it sells separate Massachusetts and Canada versions. The Department of Energy notes that most states ban unvented kerosene heaters in homes and that California and some cities and counties ban unvented natural gas heaters. Check your state and local rules before you buy. For the full picture, see is it safe to use a propane heater indoors and where to put a carbon monoxide detector.

Which One to Choose

Choose the Portable Buddy if:

  • you heat one room of about 225 sq ft or less during an outage;
  • you want the smaller unit to store with a few 1 lb cylinders;
  • you mostly need short sessions, such as warming a room for an hour or two at a time.

Choose the Big Buddy if:

  • the space is 225 to 450 sq ft, such as a garage workshop or a large family room;
  • you want the 9,000 BTU middle setting on two cylinders for longer stretches between swaps;
  • you will run it outdoors from a 20 lb tank where the manual allows it.

Avoid if: you live in Massachusetts, in Canada, or in a California dwelling, where Mr. Heater restricts indoor use; you plan to run either heater overnight while sleeping; or you have no working CO alarm. In those cases, look at electric options in our guide to heaters for power outages.

FAQ

How does the Buddy FLEX compare?

The Buddy FLEX sits between the two. Mr. Heater rates it at up to 11,000 BTU and about 275 sq ft, with about 2 hours at maximum and 3.5 hours at minimum on one 1 lb cylinder. The Mr. Heater Buddy FLEX fits a room slightly too large for the Buddy that does not need the Big Buddy; our guide to indoor propane heaters compares it with other options.

Can a Big Buddy run on one 1 lb cylinder?

It can run on low and medium, but Mr. Heater notes that a single 1 lb cylinder cannot sustain the high setting, and an undersized cylinder may frost over. For 18,000 BTU, use two cylinders or a 20 lb tank where the manual allows one.

How many 1 lb cylinders should I store for an outage?

Cylinders = hours of heat per day x days / hours per cylinder. Running a Buddy on low for 6 hours a day across 3 days: at the 5.4 hours the fuel-burn math gives, 6 x 3 / 5.4 = 3.3, so store 4; at Mr. Heater’s 6 hour rating it would be 6 x 3 / 6 = 3. Store them outdoors, never in a building, garage, or other enclosed area, as the Buddy manual directs.

Changelog: November 2026: first published.