Pick gas if you grill on weeknights and want heat in minutes; pick charcoal if you grill on weekends and want a hotter, higher-effort fire. One 20 lb propane cylinder holds about 430,000 Btu, or about 10.7 hours at full input on an example 40,000 Btu/h grill. A 22-inch charcoal kettle needs about 4 lb of briquets to run at high heat.
Side by Side
| Factor | Gas (propane) | Charcoal |
|---|---|---|
| Time to cooking heat | Preheat to 500 to 550°F (Weber) | Chimney starter, usually 10 to 15 minutes until the top coals turn gray (Weber) |
| Heat control | Knobs, per burner | Vents and how the coals are banked |
| Fuel per cook | About 0.44 gal/h at full input on a 40,000 Btu/h example grill | About 2 to 4 lb of briquets on a 22-inch grill (Kingsford) |
| Cleanup | Grates and grease tray | Grates plus an ash catcher and cold ash disposal |
| Carbon monoxide | Outdoors only | Outdoors only |
Four Differences That Matter
Fuel math for one cookout
A 20 lb cylinder holds about 4.7 gallons of propane (PERC). EIA rates propane at 91,452 Btu per gallon, so 4.7 x 91,452 = about 430,000 Btu. On an example grill drawing 40,000 Btu/h with every burner on high, that is 430,000 / 40,000 = about 10.7 hours. Most cooks run burners lower, so a cylinder usually covers several cookouts. Charcoal is simpler to count: Kingsford suggests about 2 to 3 lb of briquets for medium heat and about 4 lb for high heat on a 22-inch grill, so a weekend of three high-heat cooks is about 12 lb.
Cost per cook comes down to your local prices. Gas: gallons used x your price per gallon. Charcoal: pounds used x your price per pound. Plug in your last receipts rather than trusting a national average.
Speed and convenience
Gas starts with a knob and an igniter. Charcoal needs a chimney starter and a wait. Weber says the coals are ready to pour when the top ones turn a bit gray, usually 10 to 15 minutes depending on weather.
Heat range and control
Kingsford lists high heat on a single zone at about 450 to 550°F. A gas grill reaches the same range with a preheat, and turning a knob changes it in seconds. Charcoal changes slowly: you bank coals to one side for a direct zone and an indirect zone, then adjust vents. Both fuels can run a two-zone setup for searing plus a cooler spot.
Safety and cleanup
Use both grill types outdoors only, never in a garage, breezeway, carport, or porch (CPSC), and keep them well away from the house, deck railings, eaves, and overhanging branches (NFPA). NFPA also says to open a gas grill’s lid before lighting it. The CDC says never burn charcoal indoors, since charcoal of any color gives off carbon monoxide. For gas, check connections with soapy water, and if you smell gas, shut off the gas, do not light anything, and call your gas supplier or 911 from a safe distance. For charcoal, let used coals cool completely and keep them in a metal container with a lid, never in a trash bin. Keep children and pets at least 3 feet from either grill.
Cook to These Temperatures
The fuel does not change the food safety targets. USDA FSIS says 165°F for poultry, 160°F for ground meats, and 145°F with a 3 minute rest for whole beef, pork, and lamb cuts, and 145°F for fish. Use a probe thermometer on either grill.
Choose Gas If
- You grill several nights a week and want to start in minutes.
- You want steady heat and fast knob control.
- You do not want to deal with ash.
Choose Charcoal If
- You grill mostly on weekends and do not mind a 10 to 15 minute lighting step.
- You want a high-heat direct zone from a small, low-input grill.
- You are fine managing vents and cold ash disposal.
- Look elsewhere if you want to start cooking in under 10 minutes on a weeknight.
FAQ
Which is cheaper to run, gas or charcoal?
It depends on your prices. Use the per-cook formulas above: gallons x price per gallon for gas, pounds x price per pound for charcoal. Gas at low burner settings uses less fuel per hour than the full-input figure.
Does gas or charcoal get hotter?
Both reach the 450 to 550°F range the makers describe for high heat. Charcoal gets there with coal depth and vents, gas with burner input and a preheat. For extra searing power on gas, see infrared vs traditional gas burners.
Can I move up from gas to pellets instead?
Yes, if you want smoke flavor with set-and-hold temperature. Compare the fuel and power needs in pellet vs gas, and read propane vs natural gas if you are choosing a gas fuel. Our method is in how we choose.
Changelog: November 2026: first published.