Insulate every exposed pipe first, and add heat tape only to the runs that still freeze, because insulation slows heat loss for free but cannot add heat, while heat tape adds heat but needs power, a GFCI outlet, and careful installation. In an unheated crawl space or on a supply line next to an exterior wall, most homes end up using both: heat cable on the pipe, insulation over it as the cable maker directs.
The American Red Cross names both options in its frozen pipe guidance: pipe sleeves for exposed lines, and UL-listed heat tape or heat cable for pipes that need more protection.
Side by Side
| Factor | Heat tape or heat cable | Pipe insulation (foam or fiberglass sleeves) |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Adds heat to the pipe | Slows the pipe’s heat loss |
| Needs electricity | Yes, 120 V outlet; GFCI protection | No |
| Works in a power outage | No | Yes, keeps slowing heat loss |
| Running cost | Watts per foot x length x hours on | None after purchase |
| Protects pipes in long, deep cold | Yes, while powered | Buys time only; still water eventually reaches outdoor temperature |
| Fire and shock risk | Present if damaged, overlapped against instructions, or installed wrong (CPSC) | Very low; keep foam away from heat sources |
| Install effort | Moderate; follow the manual exactly | Easy; slit sleeves snap over the pipe |
| Typical home use | Crawl spaces, mobile home supply lines, pipes in exterior walls you can reach | Every exposed pipe in garages, basements, attics, and under sinks |
The Differences That Matter
1. Adding Heat vs Slowing Its Loss
Insulation wraps the pipe in still air, which slows how fast the water inside cools. That is often enough for pipes in a basement or under a sink, where the space stays above freezing most nights. In a crawl space that sits below freezing for days, insulation only delays the freeze, because nothing replaces the heat that leaks out. Heat cable supplies that missing heat. This is why the two are partners: insulation over the cable means the cable runs less to hold the same temperature.
2. Electricity Use, With the Math
Heat cable is rated in watts per foot. EasyHeat, for example, rates its AHB cable at 7 W per foot, with a built-in thermostat that turns it on at 38°F and off at 45°F. Use this formula for the season: watts per foot x feet x hours on per day x days / 1,000 = kilowatt-hours (kWh).
- 12 ft of 7 W cable on a crawl space supply line: 7 x 12 = 84 W while it runs.
- If the thermostat keeps it on 12 hours a day for 60 cold days (a planning assumption; colder climates run longer): 84 x 12 x 60 / 1,000 = about 60 kWh for the season.
- Multiply 60 kWh by the rate on your electric bill for the season’s cost.
Self-regulating cable lowers its own output as the pipe warms; EasyHeat lists its self-regulating line at 3, 5, or 8 W per foot measured at 50°F, so real use varies with the weather. Insulation over the cable, where the maker allows it, cuts the hours on.
3. What Happens When the Power Goes Out
Heat tape stops the moment the power drops, which is often exactly when a winter storm brings the coldest night. Insulation keeps working. If your plan depends on heat cable, pair it with insulation and a backup step: drip the faucet on that line, open cabinet doors, and know where the main shutoff is. A freeze alarm that reaches your phone helps if the house sits empty; see our guide to freeze alarms for homes.
4. Safety and Installation
The CPSC has long linked damaged and misused heat tapes to home fires. Its consumer guidance, published in releases from 1989 to 1996, says to use tape certified by a recognized lab such as UL, plug it into a grounded outlet with GFCI protection, inspect the full length each fall for cracks, charring, or bare wire, never overlap it unless the instructions allow, and never wrap it over existing insulation or use more insulation than the maker recommends. The 1996 release also warns against foam or vinyl insulation that could catch fire from a failing heat tape. Read the installation manual before buying insulation for a heated pipe, and buy the type it names.
Plug-in pipe cable goes into an existing outlet. If the pipe has no GFCI outlet within reach, have a licensed electrician add one rather than running an extension cord through a crawl space.
Choose Heat Tape If
- A pipe has frozen before, even with insulation
- The pipe runs through an unheated crawl space, a mobile home skirt, or a garage that drops well below freezing
- There is a GFCI outlet near the pipe, or you will have an electrician add one
- You will inspect the cable every fall
Avoid if the pipe sits inside a closed wall you cannot reach to inspect, or if your only protection plan would fail in an outage. Our guide to heat tape for pipes compares thermostat and self-regulating designs.
Choose Pipe Insulation If
- The pipe is in a basement, under a sink, or along a garage wall that rarely stays below freezing
- You want protection that keeps working during an outage
- You want a weekend job with no wiring and no running cost
Skip it as the only fix for a crawl space line that has frozen before; it will slow the freeze, but it will not stop it. Pair it with the habits in our guide on keeping pipes from freezing.
FAQ
Can you put insulation over heat tape?
Many heat cable makers design their products to be covered, and some specify the insulation type and a vapor seal. CPSC releases from 1989 and 1996 warn against wrapping tape over insulation, against covering it at all unless the maker allows it, and against using more insulation than recommended. Follow your cable’s manual exactly.
Is heat tape the same as heat cable?
Retail labels use the terms loosely for the same plug-in pipe heaters. Our explainer on heat tape, heat cable, and heat trace sorts out the differences.
Does newspaper work as pipe insulation?
The American Red Cross says newspaper can provide some insulation as a stopgap on exposed pipes. Replace it with proper sleeves before the season, and keep paper away from any heat source.
Should heat tape stay plugged in all winter?
Cable with a built-in thermostat only heats when the pipe is cold; the EasyHeat AHB, for example, switches on at 38°F and off at 45°F, so leaving it plugged in through the cold months is the design. Unplug it in spring, and each fall inspect the full length before plugging it back in, as the CPSC’s heat tape releases advise. A cable with no thermostat runs whenever it is plugged in, which is why the season math above matters more for those models.
Which pipes in a typical house need which fix?
In a house with a heated basement, insulation on the exposed lines near the rim joist and on any pipe in the garage usually covers it. In a house over a vented crawl space, the main supply line where it enters through the foundation is the usual candidate for heat cable plus insulation. In a mobile home, the supply line running from the ground into the skirt is the classic heat cable job.
Changelog: November 2026: first published.