Briquettes are the easier default for steady, longer burns and predictable piece size; lump charcoal is the pick when you want a hotter, faster fire and less ash. Both work in the same grill, so the choice comes down to the cook, not the equipment.
Prime Kingsford Original Charcoal Briquettes
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Prime FOGO Super Premium Hardwood Lump Charcoal
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Side by Side
| Factor | Briquettes (Kingsford Original) | Lump (FOGO) |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Pressed pieces of uniform shape; Char-Griller describes wood scraps, sawdust and additives | Pieces of real wood burned down to charcoal; the FOGO listing says no added ingredients |
| Piece size | Uniform | Mixed; listing says about 80% of the bag is pieces 4 in or longer |
| Heat | Steadier, runs cooler | Hotter |
| Burn time | Longer | Shorter |
| Ash | More | Less |
| Bag size on the listing | 16 lb | 35 lb |
Heat, burn time and ash follow a grill maker’s blog, Char-Griller’s explainer, which says briquettes “don’t burn as hot” as lump, “typically burn longer” and have “a large ash production.” It also says lump bags hold mixed piece sizes. Kingsford’s listing says its Original lights in about 15 minutes; the FOGO listing says the same for its lump. Both are listing claims, not measured results. Public burn-time numbers vary widely by brand, piece size and airflow, so treat any hour figure as rough.
Differences That Matter
Predictability
Kingsford’s own guidance for a 22 inch grill is about 2 to 3 lb of briquets for medium heat and about 4 lb for high, 450 to 550°F. A recipe like that is easier with uniform pieces. Char-Griller says lump bags hold many sizes and that lump responds well to oxygen, so you adjust with the vents. If you are new to charcoal, start with briquettes; our best charcoal grills guide covers the grills themselves.
Searing and ash
Lump burns hotter, which is why cooks commonly pick it for steaks and a short, hot sear. Char-Griller also reports less ash from lump, which means less to clear from a grill’s vents. Empty ash between cooks. See Weber kettle vs kamado for how the two grill types differ, and best lump charcoal and briquettes for more bags.
Long cooks and refuelling
For a pork shoulder in a kettle, briquettes, which Char-Griller says typically burn longer, should mean fewer top-ups. Check your grill’s manual for fuel guidance, and see best kamado grills if you cook in ceramic.
Cost per cook
Compare by weight used, not bag price. Example: a 16 lb bag at 4 lb per high-heat cook gives 16 / 4 = 4 cooks; a 35 lb bag at the same weight gives 8.75, so 8 full cooks (35 / 4). Lump burns faster, so you may use more per cook than that.
Choose Briquettes If
- You want predictable amounts and steady heat.
- You grill burgers, chicken and long indirect cooks in a kettle.
- You do not mind sweeping out more ash. Look elsewhere (lump) if you want the hottest sear.
Choose Lump If
- You sear steaks and want a hotter fire.
- You want less ash and a fuel the FOGO listing says has no added ingredients.
- You are fine sorting piece sizes and adjusting vents.
Safety
Both fuels produce carbon monoxide. CPSC says: never use a grill indoors or in a garage, breezeway, carport, porch or under a surface that will burn. Keep the grill away from the house and eaves (NFPA). Let used coals and ash cool completely and store them in a metal container with a lid, never in a trash bin.
FAQ
Can I mix lump and briquettes?
Yes, they work in the same grill. The burn rates differ, so watch the vents.
Is lump healthier?
We make no health claim. The FOGO listing says no added ingredients, but both fuels need outdoor use and proper cooking temperatures.
How did you pick these two?
They are one well-rated bag of each type from our catalog. We research specs and do not use or review the products ourselves; see how we choose.
Changelog: November 2026: first published.