Choose pellets if you want to set 225°F and walk away for a 10-hour cook; choose charcoal if you want a hotter fire, no wall outlet and a lower purchase cost. A pellet grill burns about 1 lb of pellets an hour on low and about 2 lb an hour on high (Kingsford), while a 22 inch charcoal kettle takes about 4 lb of briquets for high heat.

Side by Side

FactorCharcoalPellet
Temperature controlVents and how the coals are laid outController sets a number; auger feeds pellets
PowerNoneWall power for auger, fan and igniter
Fuel useAbout 2 to 4 lb of briquets per cook on a 22 inch kettle (Kingsford)About 1 to 2 lb of pellets per hour (Kingsford)
Stated top heatKingsford lists about 450 to 550°F for high heat on one zone500°F on Traeger Pro 575 and Ironwood; Pit Boss 500FB2 lists 180 to 500°F with a flame broiler to 1,000°F
Example grate size363 sq in (Weber 22 inch Original Kettle)575 sq in (Traeger Pro 575)
Attention neededLight the coals, watch vents and refuel on long cooksFill the hopper, set a temperature

Sources: Kingsford grill basics, Weber and Traeger product pages, and Pit Boss for the 500FB2. Pit Boss states its 1,000°F figure for the flame broiler, not for the cook chamber.

Four Differences That Matter

Fuel math for a long cook

Pellets used = hours x pounds per hour. A 10-hour brisket at about 225°F is 10 x 1 = about 10 lb, half of a 20 lb bag. A 1-hour burger cook at high heat is 1 x 2 = about 2 lb. Your cost is those pounds times your price per pound. Charcoal depends on the method: a kettle snake setup can run low and slow for up to 8 to 12 hours, per Weber, from a single layout; see Minion vs snake. For pellet burn rates in detail, read how many pellets a pellet grill uses.

Electricity and outages

Traeger lists 95 to 535 watts for its 120V pellet grills without a side burner or induction cooktop. Traeger gives no startup time, so assume a non-WiFIRE model draws 300 W for 15 minutes, then 0.4 to 0.8 A at 120 V; that uses roughly 0.54 to 1.01 kWh over 10 hours. At 18.16 cents per kWh (EIA, August 2026), that is about 10 to 18 cents. Charcoal needs no power, so it still works in an outage. The math and cord rules are in pellet grill electricity, and backup options in running one on a power station.

Searing

Charcoal puts the fire right under the grate, which is why a single-zone fire reaches the 450 to 550°F Kingsford describes. The Traeger Pro 575, Traeger Ironwood and Pit Boss 500FB2 list 500°F as the top setting, so grills like them roast and smoke well but sear less aggressively unless the model has a direct-flame feature. For more on searing, see pellet grills for searing.

Setup, cleanup and safety

Both burn fuel and give off carbon monoxide, so use them outdoors only. CPSC says to use a grill outdoors only, never indoors or in a garage, breezeway, carport or porch, and never under a surface that will burn. NFPA advises keeping grills well away from the house, deck railings, eaves and branches. Charcoal ash must cool completely and go into a metal container with a lid. A pellet grill needs its grease path cleaned on a schedule; see cleaning a pellet grill.

Choose Charcoal If

  • You want a high-heat direct zone and do not mind managing vents.
  • You have no outdoor outlet or want to cook through an outage.
  • You cook mostly steaks, burgers and chicken, with an occasional long smoke.
  • See best charcoal grills.

Choose Pellet If

  • You smoke ribs, pork shoulder or brisket and want steady temperature overnight.
  • You have an outdoor outlet and can keep pellets dry.
  • You want a larger grate, such as the 575 sq in Traeger Pro 575 against the 363 sq in kettle.
  • Look elsewhere if your main goal is a hard sear. See best pellet grills.

Cook to These Temperatures

USDA FSIS says 165°F for poultry, 160°F for ground meats, and 145°F with a 3 minute rest for whole cuts of beef, pork and lamb. Use a probe thermometer on either grill. For gas, compare pellet vs gas and gas vs charcoal.

FAQ

Which is cheaper to buy and run?

It depends on your local prices. Use the formula above: pounds x price per pound, plus a few cents of electricity for pellets.

Can a pellet grill run without power?

No. The auger, fan and igniter need electricity, so plan a backup if outages are common. Our how we choose page explains how we compare options like this.

Changelog: November 2026: first published.